The Dos and Don’ts of Mystery Shopping: Unraveling the Secrets to Successful Evaluations

Introduction: Mystery shopping is a valuable tool that helps businesses evaluate their customer experience and operational efficiency. However, for effective results, it is crucial to approach mystery shopping with a strategic mindset. In this article, we will uncover the dos and don’ts of mystery shopping, guiding you on the path to successful evaluations.


  1. Clearly Define Objectives: Before embarking on a mystery shopping program, clearly define your objectives. Determine the specific areas you want to assess, such as customer service, product knowledge, or store ambiance. Defining objectives will help you design evaluation criteria and ensure that the mystery shoppers provide actionable feedback aligned with your goals.
  2. Establish Evaluation Criteria: Establishing detailed evaluation criteria is essential to maintain consistency and objectivity in your mystery shopping program. Clearly outline the performance indicators, such as greeting time, staff engagement, or product recommendations, that the mystery shoppers should assess. Well-defined evaluation criteria ensure a standardized assessment process across multiple locations or shoppers.
  3. Recruit Reliable Mystery Shoppers: Selecting reliable and trustworthy mystery shoppers is crucial for obtaining accurate data. Partner with reputable mystery shopping agencies or create a pool of dependable shoppers who understand your requirements. Look for individuals who pay attention to detail, possess good observational skills, and can provide objective and constructive feedback.
  4. Provide Clear Instructions: To ensure consistent evaluations, provide clear instructions to your mystery shoppers. Clearly communicate your expectations, evaluation criteria, and any specific scenarios they should follow. Offering detailed guidelines and training materials will help the shoppers accurately assess the predetermined aspects and provide valuable feedback.


  1. Bias in Shopper Selection: Avoid selecting mystery shoppers who may have a personal or professional connection to your business. It is crucial to maintain objectivity and prevent any potential biases that could compromise the integrity of the evaluation. Choose shoppers who are neutral and unbiased to obtain objective feedback.
  2. Overlooking Data Analysis: Mystery shopping data is valuable only when analyzed effectively. Don’t overlook the importance of analyzing the collected data and extracting actionable insights. Look for patterns, trends, and areas of improvement across evaluations. This analysis will provide valuable feedback for decision-making and help drive meaningful changes within your business.
  3. Neglecting Feedback Communication: Mystery shopping programs often generate valuable feedback from shoppers. However, it is essential to close the feedback loop by sharing the results and insights with the relevant stakeholders. Communicate the findings, positive and negative, to employees and management teams. Sharing feedback fosters transparency, encourages accountability, and drives continuous improvement within the organization.

Conclusion: Mystery shopping, when approached strategically, can provide businesses with valuable insights into their customer experience and operational efficiency. By following the dos and don’ts outlined in this article, you can ensure successful evaluations that lead to actionable improvements. Embrace mystery shopping as a powerful tool to enhance your customer service, optimize performance, and stay ahead of the competition.

Mystery Shopping

Please feel free to call us anytime

1300 88 33 16

Alternatively if you would like us to to give you a call,
simply fill out your details below