A useful mystery shopping questionnaire turns a business objective into questions that a shopper can observe and a manager can act on. Begin with the decision the report must support, then select the questions, evidence and scoring rules.
The examples below describe a fictional retail enquiry. They are a starting point to adapt, rather than a universal scorecard or a copy of a client instrument. For overall visit coverage and responsibilities, see Designing a Mystery Shopping Program.
Define the scenario before writing the questions
Illustrative brief: the shopper seeks a product for occasional travel, gives a budget only when asked and requests an explanation of two suitable options. The assignment permits an enquiry and a written quotation, but no purchase. The shopper should not introduce a complaint, seek restricted information or push the employee outside a normal enquiry.
This boundary determines what can be scored. Product discovery and next-step explanations can be observed; payment accuracy and actual delivery cannot be established by this brief. Record the scenario version, channel and relevant trading context alongside the answers.
A sample enquiry questionnaire
| Question | Response and evidence | Design note |
|---|---|---|
| Was the customer acknowledged before assistance began? | Yes / No; record what happened and elapsed time. | Set any timing standard in the brief, with a defined start and end point. |
| Did the employee ask how the product would be used? | Yes / No / Already supplied; record the question or information supplied. | Do not penalise an employee for not asking for information already given. |
| Did the recommendation connect an option to the stated travel need? | Defined quality rating plus an example of the explanation. | Measure relevance, rather than whether any product was mentioned. |
| Did the employee explain a meaningful difference between the options? | Yes / No / No comparison opportunity; record the difference explained. | The reviewer needs an approved reference if factual accuracy is to be assessed. |
| Was the quoted price explained clearly? | Yes / No; record the price statement and relevant conditions. | Separate price explanation from recommendation quality. |
| Was an additional item suggested? | Yes / No; if yes, record the reason and response to a decline. | An add-on is not automatically a positive result. Score usefulness only when defined. |
| Was the agreed next step clear? | Defined quality rating; record action, responsibility and promised timing. | A relevant quotation or demonstration may be appropriate without a purchase. |
| What explains the important findings? | Short factual narrative with sequence and examples. | Avoid repeating every closed answer in a long paragraph. |
Replace vague or double-barrelled wording
| Weak wording | Better question | Why it is clearer |
|---|---|---|
| Was the employee helpful and knowledgeable? | Did the employee explain how the recommended option met the stated need? | One observable behaviour with evidence. |
| Was service prompt? | How long elapsed between joining the queue and initial acknowledgement? | A defined interval, rather than an undefined adjective. |
| Did the employee greet, listen and close effectively? | Separate acknowledgement, discovery and next-step questions. | One answer cannot explain three different behaviours. |
Define scoring before fieldwork
For a next-step explanation, an illustrative Green rating could require a clear action, responsible party and agreed timing. Amber could describe a proposed action with an important detail missing. Red could describe no useful next step when the scenario created a genuine opportunity. Adapt the anchors to the task; the colours alone do not define a standard.
A simple example maps Green to 2 points, Amber to 1 and Red to 0. If three eligible criteria receive 2, 1 and 0, the result is 3/6, or 50%. An authorised N/A criterion is excluded from both earned and available points. An unanswered question is not automatically N/A: it may require clarification or a report query.
Keep critical issues visible beside the total and document any override or cap in advance. If criteria carry different weights, explain the calculation and the treatment of excluded items. Never compare revised weights with an earlier total as though the instrument were unchanged.
Pilot the instrument with a realistic interaction
Check whether the scenario allows each question to be answered, two assessors interpret the wording consistently and the shopper can remember the required detail without unnatural behaviour. Remove questions that do not inform the business decision. Confirm how contradictions, missing evidence and factual checks will be handled before approving a version.
For evidence review, assessor calibration and fair interpretation, use Mystery Shopping Methodology and Quality Assurance. A short, well-designed instrument is more useful than a long list of questions that cannot be observed reliably.
Sources and scope
Prepared by Secret Customer Australia · Published 13 November 2026. Public educational adaptation of Questionnaire Design Guidance, Scenario Design Guidance, the Assessment Framework and Master Question Library Standard, with selected question-library concepts. These examples are newly written illustrations, not validated client instruments or measured industry targets.
Browse the Secret Customer Academy or discuss your objectives through our mystery shopping services.
